Being served with an intervention order is stressful — especially if you believe the allegations are exaggerated or untrue. An order can stop you going home, limit contact with your children, restrict where you can go, and affect your job and reputation. If you need to know how to fight an intervention order, act quickly and get legal advice before your first court date.
What is an intervention order?
In Victoria there are two main types:
- Family Violence Intervention Orders (FVIOs) — made under the Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic) where the applicant is a family member, current or former partner, or someone in a family-like relationship.
- Personal Safety Intervention Orders (PSIOs) — made under the Personal Safety Intervention Orders Act 2010 (Vic) where the applicant is not a family member, such as a neighbour, colleague or acquaintance. These often involve allegations of stalking, harassment or threats.
An interim order may be made before you have a chance to respond. Even if you strongly disagree with the allegations, you must obey every condition from the moment you are served. Breaching an order is a criminal offence.
How to respond to an intervention order
1. Read the application and order carefully
Check the allegations, the conditions you must follow, and your court date. A lawyer can explain exactly what you can and can’t do — for example, whether you can contact the applicant about children or collect belongings.
2. Get legal advice early
Your options include consenting to an order without admitting the allegations, negotiating different conditions, offering an undertaking, or contesting the application. The right choice depends on the evidence, any related criminal charges, and the impact on family law matters such as parenting arrangements.
3. Gather evidence
- text messages, emails, call logs and social media messages that give context;
- names of witnesses who saw relevant events;
- CCTV, photos or other records;
- evidence of other disputes that may explain why the application was made, such as a family law dispute.
Never contact the applicant, directly or through others, to discuss the case if the order prohibits it.
4. Attend court
You must attend your court date (in person or online, as directed). If you don’t, the magistrate may make a final order in your absence. If the matter isn’t resolved at the first mention, it may be adjourned to a directions hearing and then a contested hearing, where both sides give evidence.
How to contest an intervention order in Victoria: step by step
If you have decided to fight the application, it helps to understand how a contested matter moves through the Magistrates’ Court. The process is similar for family violence intervention orders and personal safety intervention orders, although the details can differ.
Step 1: The first mention
Your first court date is called the first mention. It is usually listed several weeks after the application is made (sooner if you are on bail or in custody). Plan to be at court for the whole day. The magistrate will not hear your full case at this stage. Instead, the court will ask how you want to respond, and any interim order will usually stay in place until the matter is finalised. Speak to a lawyer, or the duty lawyer, before you go into court.
Step 2: Choose your response
At or before the first mention, you will generally choose one of these options:
- Consent without admissions: you agree to a final order being made but do not accept the allegations. The court does not decide whether the allegations are true. This can avoid the cost and stress of a hearing, and you can often negotiate the conditions, for example to allow contact about children or to collect belongings.
- Undertaking: a written promise to the court and the applicant to follow certain conditions, in exchange for the application being withdrawn. The applicant must agree, and undertakings are less common where police are the applicant. Breaching an undertaking is not a criminal offence in itself, but the applicant can apply for an order again.
- Contest: you tell the court you do not agree to an order and want the magistrate to decide after hearing the evidence.
Step 3: Directions hearing or contest mention
If you contest, the matter is adjourned to a directions hearing. No evidence is heard. The court checks whether the matter can resolve, identifies the issues, and makes directions about how many witnesses will be called and how long the hearing will take. Many matters settle at this point once each side has seen the other’s position.
Step 4: Gather and prepare your evidence
The applicant must prove their case on the balance of probabilities, but you need to be ready to answer it. Useful evidence can include:
- messages, emails, call logs and social media posts that show what actually happened;
- witnesses who saw or heard the relevant events themselves (second-hand accounts carry little weight);
- CCTV, photos, location data or work records that support your account;
- documents showing a motive for the application, such as a property or parenting dispute.
Witnesses who will not come voluntarily can be summonsed. If you are not represented, you cannot personally cross-examine the protected person in a family violence matter, so having a lawyer is important.
Step 5: The contested hearing
At the hearing the applicant (or police) presents their evidence first, then you present yours. Witnesses give evidence and can be cross-examined. The magistrate then decides whether to make a final order, what conditions to include, and how long it will last. If related criminal charges are on foot, the contested hearing is often listed after those charges are dealt with.
Cross-applications
If you genuinely fear for your own safety, you can make your own application against the other party. The court can hear related applications together. A cross-application should never be used as a tactic, and the court will look closely at whether it is genuine.
What if the allegations are false?
Being accused of something you did not do is distressing, but the best response is a calm, evidence-based defence at the hearing. Do not contact the applicant to “sort it out”, even if no condition prohibits it, as this can make things worse.
People often ask whether there is a separate offence for a false statement intervention order Victoria applicants make. There is no special offence for this in the intervention order legislation, but knowingly giving false sworn evidence in court can amount to perjury under section 314 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), and knowingly making a false report to police is also an offence. Whether anyone is charged is a decision for police and prosecutors, not the respondent. Your focus in the intervention order case should be on showing the court that the order is not justified.
Costs orders
The general rule is that each party pays their own legal costs in intervention order proceedings. The court can order costs against an applicant only in limited circumstances, for example where the application was vexatious, frivolous or made in bad faith. You should not assume you will recover your costs even if you win.
Varying or revoking an order
If a final order is made, either party can later apply to vary (change) or revoke (cancel) it. A respondent usually needs the court’s permission (leave) first, and must show a real change in circumstances. The court’s main concern is the safety of the protected person. Until the court changes the order, every condition must be followed.
Appeals
You can appeal a final order to the County Court within 30 days of the decision. There is no appeal from an interim order, and lodging an appeal does not automatically suspend the order, so you must keep complying with it. If an order was made in your absence because you were never properly told about the hearing, you may instead be able to apply for a rehearing.
For official guidance, see the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria and Victoria Legal Aid’s guide to respondent options.
Common grounds for challenging an order
- No family violence or prohibited conduct occurred — the evidence does not support the allegations.
- False or exaggerated claims — for example, where an application is made to gain an advantage in a family law dispute.
- No ongoing risk — the court must be satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the conduct is likely to continue or happen again.
- Conditions are too broad — even if an order is made, its conditions may be negotiated to allow safe contact about children or access to property.
What if an order is made?
A final order lasts for the period set by the court. You may be able to apply to vary or revoke it if circumstances change, or appeal to the County Court within the time limits. An order can also affect firearms licences, some employment and visa matters, so get advice on the wider impact.
Breaching an intervention order
Contravening an intervention order is a serious criminal offence. Even a reply to a text message from the applicant can be a breach if the order prohibits contact. Penalties can include fines and imprisonment of up to two years for a single breach, and more for persistent breaches. If you are accused of a breach, get legal advice immediately and don’t speak to police without advice — see your right to silence.
Frequently asked questions
Police or the court will serve you with the application and any interim order. An order generally can’t be enforced against you until you have been served or told about it.
Often, yes. Many matters resolve by agreement, for example by consenting to an order without admissions, agreeing on conditions, giving an undertaking, or the application being withdrawn.
Tell the court at the first mention that you do not agree to the order. The matter is then adjourned to a directions hearing and, if it does not resolve, to a contested hearing where both sides give evidence and the magistrate decides whether to make a final order.
No. The order is made by agreement without the court deciding whether the allegations are true. You must still follow every condition, and a breach is a criminal offence.
Gather evidence, identify witnesses and contest the application. Knowingly giving false sworn evidence can amount to perjury, but whether anyone is charged is a matter for police and prosecutors. Your priority is defending the application itself.
Usually not. Each party generally pays their own costs. The court can order costs against an applicant only in limited situations, for example where the application was vexatious, frivolous or made in bad faith.
It lasts as long as the court orders, commonly 12 months or more, depending on the circumstances.
Penalties include fines and imprisonment of up to two years, with higher maximum penalties for persistent breaches or where the breach involves further violence.
You can appeal a final order to the County Court within 30 days of the decision. There is no appeal from an interim order, and an appeal does not automatically suspend the order.
In some contested matters, your lawyer can request further and better particulars, which are more detailed information about the allegations, so you know exactly what case you have to answer. Precise particulars help you prepare properly and avoid surprises at the hearing.
Served with an intervention order? Get advice now
Shamac Lawyers acts for applicants and respondents in intervention order matters across Melbourne and regional Victoria, including at the Bendigo and Kyneton Magistrates’ Courts. Learn more about our intervention order lawyers and how we can help you respond to a family violence intervention order.
